Google’s John Mueller answered how long it takes to recover from the June 2019 broad core algorithm update. He offered four takeaways related to how to recover from a broad core algorithm update.
Key Insights on Google Core Algorithm Updates
- Pages that lost traffic are not penalized
- Core update is about pages ranking better if they’re more relevant (or losing ranking if less relevant)
- Don’t have to wait until the next core update to recover
- It’s not generally about spam
Google’s John Mueller emphasized that the reason why sites lose rankings in Google core algorithm updates is because Google sees other sites as being more relevant. The emphasis was on relevance and lack of relevance. A key to understanding how to recover from Google’s broad core algorithm update is to think about why a web page may no longer be considered relevant.
How Long to Recover from a Google Broad Core Algorithm Update?
The person asking the question incorrectly mentioned “GoogleBot” making a decision as to when a site can recover from a core update. Googlebot is just a software program that downloads web pages, what’s known as a crawler.
It is Google’s algorithm back at the data centers that ranks all the downloaded web pages. It is those algorithms that are updated in a Core Algorithm Update.
Here is the question:
Broad Core Algorithm Updates are Not Penalties
“Got hit by the June Core Update. We’re now working on quality content. How many months do I have to wait for a recovery? Can Googlebot decide to remove a penalty without any core update?”
John Mueller answered:
Losing rankings after a Core Algorithm Update can feel like being penalized. The effect is the same. But it’s not the same.
“First of all, a core update is not a penalty. It’s not a matter of the Google algorithm saying this is a bad website.”
In a penalty Google sends the publisher a notice through Google’s Search Console about Webmaster Guideline violations.
There are no such notices when you lose rankings after a core algorithm update.
What John Mueller is communicating is that this is not about the publisher doing something bad, like violating Google’s publisher guidelines, for example a content or link spam issue.
Why Sites Lose Rankings in Core Algorithm Updates
John Mueller goes on to discuss why sites lose rankings. He explains that the reason sites lose rankings is because Google’s new algorithm has decided that certain sites are more relevant.
Here is what John Mueller said about core updates and sites that gain or lose rankings:
What Are Google Broad Core Algorithm Updates?
“It’s essentially just saying, from the way that we determine which pages are relevant, we’ve kind of changed our calculations and found other pages that we think are more relevant.
So it’s not a matter of doing anything wrong and then you fix it (and then Google recognizes it and shows it properly).
…More it’s a matter of well we didn’t think these pages were as relevant as they originally were. And these kinds of changes they can happen over time.”
Kinds of Update Ranking Losses
Although Mueller didn’t mention it, during the course of conducting site reviews, I have seen there are at least two kinds of core algorithm update losses.
Search Ranking Position Losses
In the first scenario, some sites will gain positions, causing previously high ranked pages to lose those positions in the search results.
Complete Ranking Losses
The second scenario is when a site completely loses rankings. This is more serious and generally requires a deep look at the SERPs.
Official Google Guidance
Mueller then made reference to an August 2019 blog post in which Google offered core algorithm update guidance.
How Long to Wait for Recovery from Ranking Losses
“We have a whole blog post that goes into fairly well detail on what we look at with regards to these core updates. so I would double check that.”
Lastly, John Mueller answered that Google’s algorithm is constantly updating. That means you don’t have to wait until the next core algorithm update to see if improvements to your web pages have helped. You should see ranking improvements sooner.
John didn’t mention it in his answer, but there are cases when rankings return after a subsequent algorithm update. That could be because some updates tend to be overly broad, affecting sites they didn’t intend to affect. So they might fine tune whatever change they made.
So if you see your rankings return after a core algorithm update, it’s likely that’s because they pulled back on some of the changes.
Here’s John Mueller’s comment:
Core Algorithm Ranking Losses are Not Always About Quality
“With regards to kind of seeing changes in one core update and when would you see the next batch of changes if you make significant effort to improve your website for example, in general this is something that happens on an ongoing basis.
So on the one hand we have the core updates which are kind of bigger changes in our algorithm. And on the other hand we have lots of small things that keep changing over time.
The whole Internet changes over time and with that our search results are essentially changing from day to day and they can improve from day to day as well.
So if you’ve been making significant improvements on your website then you should see these kinds of subtle changes over time as well. So it’s not a matter of waiting for a specific change to see those changes in effect.”
Mueller ended his response by repeating that a rankings loss is not a sign that something bad happened to your site.
Takeaways on Recovering from a Google Algorithm Update
“But again, these core updates are not a sign that there’s anything bad on your website.”
There are some who view every update as being about quality. When a site loses rankings, they point their finger and say it must be a low quality issue.
Others tend to see ranking issues as a matter of technical issues. Your site is slow, your redirects are chained and so on.
Quality and technical issues are legitimate concerns for ranking a site. Those issues must be addressed. But that’s not generally what these core algo updates are about.
When a site loses rankings after a core update, while technical and quality issues may exist, I prefer to keep an open mind and review everything to make sure that everything that could possibly contribute to a low ranking is addressed, especially relevance factors.
John Mueller’s statement about relevance factors is so important that he stated it twice.
If your site lost rankings in a core algo update, you may find quality and technical issues that need improvement. But in my experience auditing websites that lost rankings, it may be useful to investigate the relevance factors.
Watch the Google Webmaster Hangout here: